Archive for the ‘Uncategorized’ Category

h1

Thoughts on Top 10 Lists – Or How my Top 10 Favorites Got Halved

October 11, 2010

Some friends were over playing Thrones last night (LCG) and we tossed in a couple of games of Castle Ravenloft there at the end.  We started talking about our favorite games shortly thereafter.  One of them questioned why Game of Thrones the card game wasn’t in my top 10 list, which I thought was a very good question.

Recently, I pared down my top 10 favorite games (here at least, haven’t updated the Geek yet) to top 5.  It is a very difficult thing to quantify.   I found that there was  a large traffic jam after the first 3-4 slots, a bunch of games I very much enjoy, but no clear standouts from the rest of the pack in that second tier after the first few.

I know one thing – Descent is the most complete game experience for me, recalling the same feelings I had growing up playing Shogun and Axis and Allies.  This may be an odd comparison for some, but the level of strategy and tactics, combined with its setting and components, are spot on, for me.  I know the game isn’t perfect, of course.  But what an experience, unlike any other.

Dominion has risen for me to number 2, which is probably no surprise given my love of  and history with CCGs.   After Descent and Dominion, the number of hours I’ve put into any one game aside from Chess and CCGs drops off considerably.  But I still think of Dominion as a “board game,” separate from my current CCG I’m playing competitively.

Game of Thrones LCG is certainly one of the best games I’ve ever played.  But considering the amount of time I put into Thrones, thinking about it, preparing for tournaments, etc.,  it’s almost unfair to compare it to board games which I play occasionally for fun, even something I play as often as Dominion.

Either way, maybe Game of Thrones LCG should go in my top 5.  It is very much deserving.

Advertisements
h1

Update

October 1, 2010

Yeah, it’s been a while.  I have been playing games, though, and lots of them.  I am hoping to get back to posting here regularly, however.  Lots of my time has been spent working with FFG in various capacities with their LCG of A Game of Thrones, including designing my own card for winning the 2009 Melee World Championship. 

I also worked on some beginner decklists and the write-ups for the inserts on the new house expansions for the game:

FFG recently announced their upcoming cooperative LCG based on Lord of the Rings, and I’ve been playtesting that as well, which has been a blast. 

So it’s been a busy year, but we still work in a board game here and there. Lots of exciting stuff that I’m wanting to review or discuss, including Summoner Wars, Dungeonquest,  Arcana, Glory to Rome, Tobago, gaming with a 6-year-old, designing my own game with a friend, and much more.  We’ll see if I can’t be a little more timely in the future…